Pengumuman

Saya terpaksa update semula blog ini kerana saya dapati masih dikunjungi ramai walau pun dah hampir sebulan saya umumkan blog ini tidak akan diupdate .Saudara/saudari boleh juga ke - mountdweller88.blogspot.com (blog kedua)



Saturday, September 11, 2010

Menarik ! Analysis Of Military

Sumber dari sini

VS

There are some interesting analysis of military observer’s University of Indonesia, Andy Wijayanto, about the possibility of open between Indonesia and Malaysia in the conflict area Ambalat Block Waters. When Jakarta declared open with our neighbors, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono should take into account the state alliance that will support these in the confrontation.

Andy revealed, Malaysia has a system of defensive alliance with England, Australia, Singapore and New Zealand. The alliance called the Five Power Defense Agreement (FPDA). One of the FPDA countries agreement is a clause that an attack on one is also an attack against another .

“Malaysia just request clause to be activated. If agreed, it means Indonesia must be prepared to fight also with the UK, Australia, Singapore and New Zealand which have a fighting force far more powerful and sophisticated,” he explained after a discussion of the draft Defence and Security.

From the official website of the British High Commission, Kuala Lumpur, it is known that the FPDA was established in 1971 as a and the anticipation of an attack on Singapore and Malaysia. When 30-year commemoration FPDA in November 2001, the five member states agreed to establish a long-term cooperation. One of them, agreements to support each other if any of its member countries that attacked another country. This year, the FPDA to focus his review on . With that focus, the possibility of four other countries to support Malaysia in the confrontation with Indonesia to be bigger.

Not only that. If in our country will face a confrontation with the British, the country will very likely ask for an article five of NATO () enabled. Articles similar to NATO’s five FPDA that essentially said that the attack suffered by one is considered as an attack on other member states and must be faced together. Therefore, could widen the confrontation with Malaysia and Indonesia must make a deal with NATO member countries.

“So, the effect will be successive. That is what must be considered carefully by the President of SBY before the declaration of confrontation with Malaysia. People must understand this is not so dark eyes urging with Malaysia,” said Andy.

This is the comparison between Malaysian and Indonesian military forces

MALAYSIA

Military Affairs was neighbor called the Army of Kings Malaysia. At the beginning of its establishment, the British-made military equipment is widely used this country. Now they are using equipment from several countries, including Indonesia-made aircraft.

  • 1. Warship
  • A dive boat equipped with 20 mm cannon
  • Two fast ships transport troops
  • Four French-made patrol boats were Exocet MM38 missiles and cannon Bofors
  • 24 warships based in four places: Moss, Sandakan Sabah Kuantan and Labuan. KD Kerambit around Ambalat is one time based in Sandakan, Sabah.
  • Two South Korean-made patrol boats equipped with cannon Creusot Loire 100 mm, 30 mm Emerlac, repellent and anti-submarine weapons. This ship is based in Kuantan
  • Four Swedish-made vessel equipped with Exocet MM38 missiles, 57 mm Bofors and 40 mm Bofors based.
  • Four ships Frigate, two of which were purchased secondhand from the British Royal Navy.
  • Six German-made ship Corvette – Four patrol boats repellent Italian-made mines
  • Two ships Multi Purpose Command and Support Ship made in Germany and South Korea
  • One ship Sealift
  • Two ships Hydro
  • 2. Fighter
  • F-5 E – Hawk MK108 based in Alor Setar, Kuantan, Labuan
  • Hawk MK-208 based in Alor Setar, Kuantan, Labuan
  • Eight F/A-18D based in Alor Setar
  • MIG-29 based in Kuantan
  • SU-30 based in Kuantan
  • F-28 based in Kuala Lumpur
  • Falcon based in Kuala Lumpur – Beech 200T based in Kuala Lumpur
  • C-130H based in Kuala Lumpur
  • CN-235 based in Kuala Lumpur
  • S61A-4 based in Kuala Lumpur, Kuching and Labuan
  • AS61N-one based in Kuala Lumpur
  • S70A-34 personnel based in Kuala Lumpur
  • 3. The number of soldiers of all forces: 196 042 (2002)
  • The military budget per year: US1, 69 trillion (2.03 percent of GDP)

INDONESIA

Embargo on the purchase of military equipment from the U.S. to build military equipment to fall out of Indonesia. Newest fighter plane, Sukhoi SU-27 SK and SU-30 MK Russian-made, one still missing had no weapons. As of 12 combat aircraft “mainstay”, the F-16, two of whom had fallen and only eight are ready to fly.

  • 1. Aircraft and Heli
  • 8 units Hawk MK 109 based in Pekanbaru, Pontianak
  • 32 units Hawk MK 209 based in Pekanbaru, Pontianak
  • 6 units CN235 based at Halim
  • Eight units F27-400m based at Halim
  • SF260MS/WS based at Halim
  • B707-3MIC
  • 7 units 400m F27 aircraft
  • F28-1000/3000
  • L100-30
  • C-130H-30 based at Halim
  • NAS332L1
  • L100-30
  • EC-120B
  • 12 units Heli Bell 47G-3B-1 based at kalijati
  • 5 units F-16a based in Madison
  • 5 units F-16B based in Madison
  • F-5E based in Madison
  • F-5F based in Madison
  • Based in Madison Hawk Mk53
  • 2 units Su-27SK based in Makassar
  • 2 units Su-30MK based in Makassar
  • NC212M-100/200 based in Malang
  • Ce 401A based in Malang
  • Ce 402A based in Malang
  • 10 units Bronco OV-10F aircraft in Malang Warship
  • 114 units fleet of various types (third for routine operations, a third for training, and the remainder for maintenance) Personnel
  • 2. The number of soldiers (all forces): 250 thousand people
  • The military budget per year: U.S. $ 1 trillion (1.3 percent of GDP)

So Should Indonesia and Malaysia go into Field, even they both are brother and neighbor ?

Ambalat Block Water

12 comments:

  1. analsis yg menarik!!kesimpulan nya kekuatan ketenteraan negara hanya bergantung semata2 kepada FDPA..bagi saya ini menunjukkan kelemahan bukan kekuatan pertahanan negara..utk mempertahankan diri terpaksa bergantung kepada negara orang..bagaimana fdpa bertindak membelakangkan perjanjian tersebuat atau bertindak kecuali..waktu tu adakah Malaysia akan meratap merayu kepada musuh supaya tidak menyerang nya? Cuba bayangkan jika perangan anatara Malaysia dan Singapura..adakah Britain, Australia akan menyokonng Malaysia atau Singapore??tepuk dada tanya sendiri..my analisis is our defence are so damn week and something is not.. right!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Pertahanan Malaysia memang lemah. Alat kelengkapan tentera banyak yang secondhand.Ada jet pejuang tak ada enjin, ada kapal selam tak boleh menyelam. Pokok kepada kelemahan ini adalah pak2 menteri banyak yang korup dan penyamun tarbus. Malahan berperang dengan Singapura Malaysia pasti tewas, tak perlu berperang dengan Indonesia.

    ReplyDelete
  3. hmmm...nampaknya terpaksalah cancel trip ke sana jika tak selamat! Tak tahu lah naper org sana beriya benar nak provoke Malaysia...ada ajer isu mereka.Kat sini, dah tak nampak pekerja kilang dari indonesia...rata2 terdiri dari warga india atau sri lanka. Cuma pembantu rumah jer masih ramai dari Indonesia...tu pun sebab sukar nak dapatkan warga lain di agensi. Tak bagus pun kena terima sebab tak banyak pilihan :(

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kita kena ada R&D sendiri buat semua benda berkaitan warfare & its maintenance. Jangan kita harap syarikat kroni pak menteri supply..mesti memabzir, tiris punya..kopak la bajet negara.

    Pegawai-2 & ex-staff tentera pun ada yg buat duit atas angin. Salahguna kuasa. Mana rasuah tak berleluasa?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Peperangan tak meletus antara sebuah negara dengan sebuah negara lain atau sebuah negara dengan sekumpulan negara-negara lain dalam sekelip mata saja. Ada proses dan prosedurnya. Lihat contoh di Iraq dan di Afghanistan. Perlu diadakan rundingan (pertama antara kedua pihak yang berkonflik, kedua yang dikendalikan oleh sebuah negara ketiga dan jika gagal, dibawa ke PBB) untuk menyelesaikan masalah di meja rundingan. Pada masa yang sama, jika keadaan kelihatan tegang, amaran kepada rakyat supaya pulang ke negara masing-masing akan diumumkan. Duta serta kaki tangan kedutaan akan dipanggil pulang tapi hubungan diplomatik belum diputuskan.Banyak petunjuk (indicators) lain yang berlaku sebelum perang berlaku. Peperangan tak serupa macam main perang-perang. Kos yang perlu dibayar terlalu amat tinggi bukan saja disegi wang ringgit tapi juga dari segi yag lain.Lihat saja keadaan di Iraq.Walaupun US dan sekutunya menang,adakah mereka berjaya melahirkan keamanan hakiki di sana? Begitu juga di Afghanistan. Perang masih berlarutan walaupun Taliban sudah digulingkan.Bagaimanapula dengan rakyat kedua buah negara?Itu sebab diplomasi memainkan peranan yang penting, bukan saja diplomasi yang dilaksanakan oleh Wisma Putra tapi juga diplomasi ketenteraan yang dilakukan oleh ATM.
    FPDA bukan satu perjanjian (agreement) tapi satu peraturan (Five Power Defence Arrangement).

    ReplyDelete
  6. Analisis ni tak tau la tahu bila punya. Tak up to date langsung F18 mana ada kat alor setar ? Submarine ? 6 NGPV ?

    ReplyDelete
  7. jangan main cakap je jet pejuang takdak enjin, kapal selam tak leh menyelam. semua tu dakyah pembangkang. ingat ATM kita ni bodo sangat ka sampai nak biaq gitu ja. apa da. pikiaq tu bagi ada akai skit la.

    ReplyDelete
  8. anon 1..ko percaya website and analysis indon watpe..dorang bukan tau data tepat kekuatan malaysia...pergi duk negara lain la kalau tak yakin dengan negara sendiri..berambus n nyah ko!

    ReplyDelete
  9. assalamualikum encik....

    carilah fakta mengenai kekuatan ATM pula....

    cuba tanya dari anak sulung encik.encik ada sumber maklumat kekuatan TLDM,gunakanlah untuk analisa encik.

    berilah analisa yang seimbang....

    BIAR ADIL....kata sokong PR...
    analisa pun kena la adil...

    ReplyDelete
  10. ya betul pak din
    Biaq ALONG pulak yang buat analisis

    ReplyDelete
  11. whatever it is..
    the war shouldn't be done.

    it will suffer all of the people.

    regards,

    Indonesia Hits

    http://indonesia-hits.com

    note : thanks for placing my article here..

    ReplyDelete

Cakaplah apa saja yang benar asalkan tidak menghina sesiapa